Kierkegaards ethic of lovetxtkierkegaards ethic of lovepdf. He thereby implies love for ones friends and for oneself. I am only too conscious that there are many themes in kierkegaard as. Kierkegaard on aesthetic, ethical and religious modes of life kierkegaards early works and eitheror, fear and trembling and stages on lifes way were all written under pseudonyms. Despair is a sickness in the spirit, in the self, and so it may assume a triple form. If we get up for ourselves, we live for pleasure, interest or boredom the aesthetic life. Kierkegaards works of love is a late book in his extensive writings. Translated and published in portugese by editora vida, 2003. See more ideas about soren kierkegaard, kierkegaard quotes and famous philosophy quotes. He claims that the story of abrahams willingness to sacrifice his son for god, found in genesis 22, has long been exalted as a story that epitomizes faith. Kierkegaard on natural and commanded love alastair hannay part 3. If we get up for others, we live according to universal moral principles the. The command to love, however, is not a command to follow abstract duty, it is a command to be what you already are, to become what you are, since love is part of human.
The role of love in the thought of kant and kierkegaard. Kierkegaards ethic of lovetxtkierkegaards ethic of. In kierkegaards when love is secure, chapter 33 of the provocations, he viewed greatest happiness can change into greatest torment when it is a duty to love. The relation between faith and ethics in kierkegaards. The relation between faith and ethics in kierkegaards fear. The spiritual journey of u2, steve stockman says that u2 inhabits that dangerous and exhilarating space that connects spiritual and physical, mortal and divine. Gregor smith notes that kierkegaards study of love reaches to the heart of christian thought. Whereas the ethic put forward in fear and trembling is chiefly polemical and tactical in nature, that articu lated in uvrks of love 1847 represents the mature expression of the new or second ethic to which kierkegaard had gestured in the early paragraphs. Kierkegaard brought this potent mixture of discourses to bear as social. While i agree with turner and turrells general presentation of levinass existential conception of god and ethics, i reflect primarily on the reference the authors make to kierkegaard as an existentialist forefather of levinas. These include the limits of selfreliance, the source of joy and lifeaffirmation, and the. Works of love can be compared to purity of heart is to will one thing in its emphasis on the ethical aspects of christianity. This book took five years to write and forms his basis of divine command theory of ethics.
Of course this seems confusing in terms of the subject at hand, but what one can pull out from that concept is the fact that the individual, in kierkegaards love ethic, takes a back seat to the neighbor. Mar 03, 2009 kierkegaard on aesthetic, ethical and religious modes of life kierkegaards early works and eitheror, fear and trembling and stages on lifes way were all written under pseudonyms. He views works of love as seminal in the corpus of kierkegaard s authorship. In particular, i suggest that a study of their views of the scriptural. It seems to me that a more fruitful comparison of their ethics is possible by drawing on the more mature ethical accounts of both thinkers. Kierkegaard does not use fear and trembling to represent how the ethical life appears from within the life of faith, as some have believed. Additionally, this form of divine command theory resists the fundamental objections often posed against a. Kierkegaards the seducers diary describes a man johanness calculated scheme to seduce a young girl cordelia into falling in love with him.
In the nicomachean ethics, aristotle claims the virtuous person regards a friend as. The various kinds and conditions of love are a common theme for kierkegaard, beginning with his early eitheror, through the diary of the seducer and judge williams eulogy on married love, to his last work, on the changelessness of gods. In the bible pdf download, christ says you shall love, or you ought to love as kierkegaard says in an echo of kants formulation of moral law as a universal ought. It is one of the works which he published under his own name, as opposed to his more famous pseudonymous works. He views works of love as seminal in the corpus of kierkegaards authorship. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Kierkegaard, importantly, is not an ethicist and does not provide a normative ethical system. Loss of the world in kierkegaards ethics, in kierkegaard. Making sense of kierkegaards philosophical fragments 1992. In the last chapter, we examined several points of disagreement between kierkegaard and nietzsche and ended by summarizing some of the most significant points of divergence between them. Kierkegaard presents a form of divine command theory of moral obligation similar to accounts developed by robert adams and philip quinn. Since neither of these realities are explicit in works of love, the.
Selflove and neighbor love in kierkegaards ethics antony a. For this reason, evans identifies kierkegaards ethic as a kind of selfactualization ethic, a term that is meant to indicate that the central ethical task lies in becoming oneself, understood as actualizing the potential self that god intends one to become. Self love and neighbor love in kierkegaards ethics abstract. Since neither of these realities are explicit in works of love, the first part. Kierkegaard wanted to enter into different ways of seeing the world in order to help people see their own situations more clearly, and in order that they might be. Additionally, this form of divine command theory resists the fundamental objections often posed against a religiously grounded ethic. It does not follow from the necessity clause that gods commands are a sufficient ground of moral obligation, but it. The aesthetic, ethical, and religious forms of life. Despite kierkegaard s own rather disparaging later remarks about it.
When he talks about the ethical, he is talking about the middle sphere in his three spheres, as distinct from the aesthetic and the religious. In this chapter kierkegaard also introduces the element of purity, as if to recall the former work. In immediacy and reflection in kierkegaards thought, edited by paul cruysberghs, johan tails, and karliels verstrynge, 100119. A critique of kierkegaards works of love abstract in volume i of works of love, kierkegaard condemns preferential, earthly love and extols the virtues of impartial, christian love. Existentialism kierkegaar d3 works the concept of irony, with continual reference to socrates 1841 s. All three forms of life are attempts to escape the universal condition of despair, according to kierkegaard. Kierkegaard s the seducer s diary describes a man johannes s calculated scheme to seduce a young girl cordelia into falling in love with him. It was published only four days later than the fragments, so it clearly fits within kirkconnell s chosen timeframe, and it is centrally concerned with the issue of sin original sin, the fall. Kierkegaards ethic of love and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. If love is a duty of a person then love becomes eternally secured, secured from ravages. Here is a great article by the philosopher jeff mason, in which he explains kierkegaards different forms of life. Stephen evans explains and defends kierkegaards account of moral obligations as rooted in gods commands, the fundamental command being you shall love your neighbour as yourself. Kierkegaards literary output was vast, even though he died at age 42. Kierkegaards fear and trembling edited by daniel conway.
Kierkegaard and the philosophy of love reading religion. Fear and trembling is not the place to look for an account of kierkegaards ethical views, because it is not a book about ethics but faith, written by someone who neither has faith nor an understanding of it. This article is a brief commentary on donald turner and ford turrells the nonexistent god. It appeared in 1847, a year after kierkegaard considered his work as a writer to be complete. The work will be of interest not only to those interested in kierkegaard, but also to those interested in the relation between ethics and religion, especially. As such, he thinks self love and neighbor love should be symmetrical, similar in kind as well as degree. Article information, pdf download for the divine relationship ethics of. The problem of preferential love in kierkegaards works of love, journal of religious ethics 36.
The divine relationship ethics of kierkegaards lovesleuth in. From eitheror to philosophical fragments, continuum, 2008, 177pp. Rather than attempting a metaphysics on the nature of love as an abstract concept, which has often been the task of theologians and philosophers, strawser takes a phenomenological approach to the consciousness of the lover and. Dec 31, 20 here is a great article by the philosopher jeff mason, in which he explains kierkegaards different forms of life. On the one hand, he endorses the biblical command to love our neighbors as ourselves. Given this kierkegaard believes that the person of faith must not have preferential love for anyone, including himselfherself. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading kierkegaards ethic of love.
This book took five years to write and forms his basis of. I conclude by showing that kierkegaards failure to differentiate between the contents of different faithbased actions leads his faithbased religious ethic to fall into an ethical antinomy. But much more puzzling is the omission of any discussion of the concept of anxiety. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Of course this seems confusing in terms of the subject at hand, but what one can pull out from that concept is the fact that the individual, in kierkegaards love ethic, takes a. Jan 27, 2007 in the bible pdf download, christ says you shall love, or you ought to love as kierkegaard says in an echo of kants formulation of moral law as a universal ought. Kierkegaard and the ethics of sacrifice as part of the ethics of love 11 references 1 c. This kierkegaardian ethic, found principally in works of love, has advantages over its contemporary secular rivals, such as evolutionary naturalism, social contract theories, and moral relativism. Transcendence, humanity, and ethics in emmanuel levinas. Glenn kirkconnell, kierkegaard on ethics and religion. B is a second immediacy in relation to god, one spring ing from a. Divine commands and moral obligations kindle edition by evans, c. Poetic love is rooted in the temporal, and because of this it is extremely vulnerable. Stephen evans explains and defends kierkegaards account of moral obligations as rooted in gods commands, the fundamental command.
The work will be of interest not only to those interested in kierkegaard, but also to those interested in the relation between ethics and religion, especially questions about whether morality can or must have a. I conclude by showing that kierkegaard s failure to differentiate between the contents of different faithbased actions leads his faithbased religious ethic to fall into an ethical antinomy. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading kierkegaard s ethic of love. Soren kierkegaard stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Jamie ferreira, the problematic agapeistic idealagain, in ethics, love, and faith in kierkegaard. Described by updike as a wound disguised as a boast this novelessaydiary is elegiac in its cold lack of apology. In each there is an ethical call to love in action. Yet he claims that his vision of christianity leaves room for earthly relationships in their full richness. The ethical in fear and trembling oxford scholarship. Stephen evans the work will be of interest not only to those interested in kierkegaard, but also to those interested in the relation between ethics and religion, especially questions about whether morality can or must have a religious foundation. Kierkegaards ethic of love this page intentionally left blank kierkegaards ethic of love divine commands and mora.
Love and the discipline of philosophy rick anthony furtak 6. Should we get up for ourselves, for others, or for the christian god. Oxford university press, 2004 pocket dictionary of philosophy of religion and apologetics downers grove, illinois. His work crosses the boundaries of philosophy, theology, psychology, literary criticism, devotional literature and fiction. Soren kierkegaard jeff mason on kierkegaards three forms of life. Michael strawsers book, kierkegaard and the philosophy of love, is an important contribution to understanding the universal human experience of love.
447 298 1057 1267 584 415 622 252 566 402 1252 1039 1353 625 1372 9 1230 760 573 20 492 1281 515 267 1404 1022 1048 1472 1035 1256 496 1447 1396 353 1424 838